Question:
What is the difference between a switch, hub, and router?
anonymous
2006-09-13 07:28:35 UTC
Aside from the fact that it states what it is on the device, can anyone tell me the specific differences between these items? When do you use which device? Also when would you choose a wireless device or a hard wired?
thanks
Tina
Eight answers:
anonymous
2006-09-13 07:51:15 UTC
Switches and hubs are smaller simpler devices that are used to connect LANs or WANs.



A traditional router is used to connect multiple LANs or WANs together, but a home router is used to connect a home LAN to the internet.
Amadeus
2006-09-13 07:46:37 UTC
Tina lets make this simple.



A switch, can route multiple computer and high speed for example 10/100 each device or computer on the network can talk to each other at 10/100 no bottle neck.



A Hub, the hub will share the bandwidth between devices. If multiple devices or computer are on the same hub. The bandwidth is share, which will decrease as more users are accessing it.



A Router, is a device which will route IP information from 1 router to another. Example. If you computer is on 1 network and your friends computer is on another. When requesting information on your computer cant find it on your network, the router will then send a request out to the Internet and look for the correct information. Such as sending emails.



To sum this up if your just trying to make a simple multi computer network in your home, which all computer can go out to the inter net. I would suggest a Router with a built in switch.These can router can even have wireless access.



I use a Wireless router from Belkin which also has 4 hard wried ports. It great for my computer and my wireless laptop.



Good Luck
oklatom
2006-09-13 07:47:41 UTC
A hub is typically the least expensive, least intelligent, and least complicated of the three. Its job is very, very simple: anything that comes in one port is sent out to the others. That's it. Every computer connected to the hub "sees" everything that every other computer on the hub sees. The hub itself is blissfully ignorant of the data being transmitted. For years, simple hubs have been quick and easy ways to connect computers in small networks.



A switch does essentially what a hub does, but more efficiently. By paying attention to the traffic that comes across it, it can "learn" where particular addresses are. For example, if it sees traffic from machine A coming in on port 2, it now knows that machine A is connected to that port, and that traffic to machine A needs to only be sent to that port and not any of the others. The net result of using a switch over a hub is that most of the network traffic only goes where it needs to, rather than to every port. On busy networks, this can make the network significantly faster.



A router is the smartest, and most complicated of the bunch. Routers come in all shapes and sizes, from the small four-port broadband routers that are very popular right now, to the large industrial strength devices that drive the internet itself. A simple way to think of a router is as a computer that can be programmed to understand, possibly manipulate, and route the data its being asked to handle. For example, broadband routers include the ability to "hide" computers behind a type of firewall, which involves slightly modifying the packets of network traffic as they traverse the device. All routers include some kind of user interface for configuring how the router will treat traffic. The really large routers include the equivalent of a full-blown programming language to describe how they should operate, as well as the ability to communicate with other routers to describe or determine the best way to get network traffic from point A to point B.



(network speed comes into it, but that's a whole different subject)
Analyst
2006-09-13 07:46:23 UTC
Lots of technojargon around, but the basic idea is that switches are more powerful than hubs. A hub, in effect, forces all the computers on the hub to share in the data load... so if one person downloads a big file, all on the network suffer with reduced netowork speed. But a switch is more advanced, and is able to send the data just to that one person, saving the rest of the network from suffering.



The router is the next level: its a switch with the ability to link to other networks. If you think of all the computers in the Sales dept on 1 switch, and all the computers in the Acct dept on another switch, a router can link those networks together.



Most consumer devices for linking up computers in a house are basically routers: They are switch oriented (instead of hubs) and link your home network to the cable company or DSL or whatever's network. So, for basic home stuff, any router or switch will be useful.



The wireless vs. hardwired all depends on your situation:

1) Wireless is easier to manage in some ways: no wires to deal with, no stacks of plugs, etc. However, make sure to understand how wireless security works... that can get annoying. Hardwired has fewer security issues in many ways, but that's debatable as things get more complex.



2) Wired is faster at this point. Some of the newest wireless formats allow more than 54mbs (old hardwire was just 10mb) but wired networks allow 100mb. Note that for a home network, the dsl or cable modem is probably only 6mb, so the 100mb or 54mb is great from computer to computer (printing, file transfer, gaming) but to the outside world, you are limited by the speed of that outside connection.



Over time, wireless will continue to increase in speed and wired networks, though also going faster, will probably fade out in many homes.



Make sure to read reviews before buying. Some recent models in the "pre-N", supposedly the newest and fastest, as of this writing are often no faster than the previous generation, but cost more. This too will be fixed, but reviews will help you buy the right thing now. Tech.yahoo.com, Cnet, and PCWorld are all very helpful for this.
Erinca
2006-09-13 07:39:44 UTC
A hub is typically the least expensive, least intelligent, and least complicated of the three. Its job is very, very simple: anything that comes in one port is sent out to the others. That's it. Every computer connected to the hub "sees" everything that every other computer on the hub sees. The hub itself is blissfully ignorant of the data being transmitted. For years, simple hubs have been quick and easy ways to connect computers in small networks.



A switch does essentially what a hub does, but more efficiently. By paying attention to the traffic that comes across it, it can "learn" where particular addresses are. For example, if it sees traffic from machine A coming in on port 2, it now knows that machine A is connected to that port, and that traffic to machine A needs to only be sent to that port and not any of the others. The net result of using a switch over a hub is that most of the network traffic only goes where it needs to, rather than to every port. On busy networks, this can make the network significantly faster.



A router is the smartest, and most complicated of the bunch. Routers come in all shapes and sizes, from the small four-port broadband routers that are very popular right now, to the large industrial strength devices that drive the internet itself. A simple way to think of a router is as a computer that can be programmed to understand, possibly manipulate, and route the data its being asked to handle. For example, broadband routers include the ability to "hide" computers behind a type of firewall, which involves slightly modifying the packets of network traffic as they traverse the device. All routers include some kind of user interface for configuring how the router will treat traffic. The really large routers include the equivalent of a full-blown programming language to describe how they should operate, as well as the ability to communicate with other routers to describe or determine the best way to get network traffic from point A to point B.



OR



HUB When Ethernet was originally designed it used a single fat coax called a backbone. Individual hosts were physically connected to the backbone. This created a party line. Each host has to listen for the backbone to be idle before it started talking. It is possible more then one host will start talking at the same time, in that case the messages collide making them unintelligible. This condition is detected each transmitter stops talking and waits a variable interval before attempting to talk again. The Ethernet network is called a collision domain, since all devices must wait until the line is clear, and may inadvertently interfere with one another.

When Ethernet was modified to run over Unshielded Twisted Pair (UTP) Category rated wiring the original coax backbone was shrunk within the hub, called a collapsed backbone. Functionally a hub operates exactly as the old coax backbone. The ports on the hub provide a point-to-point connection to the Ethernet interface in each computer. With a hub each node must wait for the network to be idle and detect collisions between multiple nodes.



SWITCH As Ethernet networks grew in speed and size the party line nature was recognized as a performance limitation. Switches eliminate the collision domain and work much like the telephone switching system.

When an Ethernet packet arrives at the switch the destination MAC address is examined and the packet is switched to the proper port. Each Ethernet interface has a Media Access Controller (MAC) 48-bit address assigned by the hardware vendor. The switch remembers which MAC addresses are connected to each port. If the Switch does not know which port to use it floods the packet to all ports. When it gets a response it updates its internal MAC address table.

This means Port A can talk to C at the same time F is taking to B. This greatly increases overall performance even though it does not change the speed of individual connections. Because the collision domain is eliminated connections are able to use full duplex, hosts can transmit and receive at the same time improving performance even more.



ROUTER A router is used to interconnect multiple networks. The Internet is literally Internetwork -- a network of networks. Internet router’s work on IP addresses to determine how best to interconnect the sender to the destination. Because router’s work at the IP layer different physical networks can be interconnected, Ethernet, Token Ring, Sonet, even RS232 serial used for dialup can carry IP packets.

Routers intended for home use include Network Address Translation (NAT). This allows a single address assigned by the ISP to be shared by multiple hosts connected to the local network.
anonymous
2006-09-13 07:36:36 UTC
SWITCH

A switch is a device for changing the course (or flow) of a circuit.The terms 10/100 switch, 10/100 hub and 10/100 card refer to Ethernet switches, hubs and network cards capable of connecting to 10Mbit/s (10BASE-T) and 100Mbit/s (100BASE-T) network devices on the same interface port, adjusting their speed automatically.

When 100Mbit/s Ethernet was introduced, early devices were limited to the higher speed. Today, automatic speed switching is a standard feature on even the cheapest hardware, and even triple-speed 1000/100/10Mbit/s ports are commonplace.





HUB

An Ethernet hub or concentrator is a device for connecting multiple twisted pair or fibre optic Ethernet devices together, making them act as a single segment. It works at the physical layer of the OSI model, repeating the signal received at one port out each of the other ports (but not the original one). The device is thus a form of multiport repeater. Ethernet hubs are also responsible for forwarding a jam signal to all ports if it detects a collision.

Hubs also often come with a BNC and/or AUI connector to allow connection to legacy 10BASE2 or 10BASE5 network segments. The availability of low-priced Ethernet switches has largely rendered hubs obsolete but they are still seen in older installations and more specialist applications.







ROUTER

A router is a computer networking device that forwards data packets across a network toward their destinations, through a process known as routing. Routing occurs at layer 3 (the Network layer e.g. IP) of the OSI seven-layer protocol stack



Use a router coz its a intellegent device among the 3

It stores user id & pwd to get u connected to internet & u can have multiple connections (networking)....

Wired & wireless Routers are equally good i would suggest Wireless as they will have a hardwired coonecion option too
mohsen m
2006-09-13 08:03:05 UTC
OK just a brief

as ur name ,in network we have one name for every device ,it is MAC address ,the hub read ur mac address in a group that every body can hear ,but just the device that hub called its name will answer and data transfer will start

the switch do more ,the switch will find u the it will want of u to start transfer ,it means the switch just will target u ,and others hear nothing that one stream from one source is transferring to u

the router is the device that redirect letters to special way ,line ,or targets ,may be even drop them to no place ( fall) or specified place ,in router ur address named ip ,both sides have ip ,the router also has ip ,and router start to guide data stream from its in place (its wic or T1 ) to out (wic or T1 ).

u cant see hubs this days because switches are most smarter and now we more use switches

routers also u can find most in Internet and large local networks

routers will find also the shortest path to target for u

be success
rockie
2006-09-13 07:45:13 UTC
hey dude.... jus chk this out!!!



Hubs and Switches both glue the PCs in a network together, a switch is more expensive and a network built with switches is generally considered faster than one built with hubs. Why?



When a HUB receives a packet (also called chunk) of data at one of its ports from a PC on the network, den it transmits the packet to all of its ports and to all of the other PCs on the network. If two or more PCs on the network try to send packets at the same time, den a collision is said to occur betwwen those 2 packets. When this happens, then all of the PCs have to go though a routine to resolve the conflict.



where as the Switch automatically divides the network into multiple segments, acts as a high-speed, selective bridge between the segments, and supports simultaneous connections of multiple pairs of computers which don't compete with other pairs of computers for network bandwidth. It accomplishes this by maintaining a table of each destination address and its port. When the switch receives a packet, it reads the destination address from the header information in the packet, establishes a temporary connection between the source and destination ports, sends the packet on its way, and then terminates the connection.



letz see abt the router...

Most Routers (also called as broadband routers ) are a combination Switch (or hub) and Network Address Translator. They usually include a :

--Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (DHCP) server,

--Domain Name Service (DNS)

--Proxy server, and

--a hardware firewall to protect the Local Area Network (LAN)

from malicious intrusion from the Internet.



datz it!!!!


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...